Skip to main content

Emsal Denetim

A Decision Regarding the Determination of Income Obtained from New Investments

A Decision Regarding the Determination of Income Obtained from New Investments

I occasionally share important court decisions that I find noteworthy with you, my readers. Today, I will discuss a Council of State (Danıştay) ruling related to tax reductions in incentivized investments.

Legal Regulation

In incentivized investments, the reduced corporate tax rate generally applies to the income derived from the investment.

Although this is the rule, from the start date of the investment and limited to the investment period, the reduced rate can also be applied to income from other activities of the investor, within certain limits and by offsetting the contribution amount to the investment.

This design of the incentive requires calculating the income derived from the investment with an incentive certificate, which is far from easy. Especially in expansion investments and some types of investments, this calculation is almost impossible. Considering this, for expansion investments:

  • If the income derived from the investment can be identified by tracking separate accounts within the business as a whole, the reduced rate will apply to this income.

  • If the income cannot be separately identified, the reduced rate applicable income is found by proportioning the amount of the expansion investment to the total fixed asset amount recorded in the company’s assets at the end of the period.

This method is only foreseen for expansion investments but it is accepted that the same formula can be used for investments other than completely new ones.

For completely new investments, it is expected that the income derived from the incentivized investment be identified by tracking separate accounts, the accounting system be adapted to make this calculation, and that the income be correctly calculated.

How feasible this is can be debated. Often, it is not possible to determine the income accurately. While it may be possible to track income from new investments to some extent separately, identifying which revenues and expenses relate to the incentivized investment is not always possible. This forces the preference of one of two alternatives:

  1. Apply the formula foreseen for expansion investments also to income obtained from completely new investments,

  2. Directly consider revenue, costs, and expenses related to completely new investments, and allocate unrelated revenues, costs, and expenses by certain distribution keys to find the most accurate income derived from the investment.

The Council of State decision I will discuss is precisely about this issue. First, I will summarize the ruling, then share my evaluation.


Summary of the Decision

According to the summary in the Council of State ruling, in the case at hand, the plaintiff company made an incentivized investment classified as a completely new investment but could not precisely determine the income from the new investment. Therefore, the company used its own distribution key to calculate the income. Based on a tax audit report prepared against the company, the tax authority argued that when income related to the completely new investment cannot be separately identified, the best distribution key to be used is the one foreseen for expansion investments. The company’s use of its own distribution key without legal basis to determine the reduced corporate tax base was deemed contrary to regulations. Consequently, the corporate tax base was recalculated, and an additional tax assessment was made. This assessment was contested.

The Tax Court examining the case ruled that:

  • The Corporate Tax Law does not contain a provision allowing the distribution key foreseen for expansion investments to be applied to completely new investments when income cannot be separately determined. However, it found no legal obstacle to using a suitable distribution key that fits the nature of the case to separate the income attributable to the completely new investment from the total income, and to consider this income in the application of the reduced corporate tax rate.

  • The distribution key used by the plaintiff company was not evaluated for its suitability to the nature of the business. It was deemed unlawful to calculate the reduced corporate tax base by analogy with the distribution key foreseen for expansion investments.

Accordingly, the court partially accepted the case.

The Regional Administrative Court upheld this decision with the same reasoning and rejected the appeal. The Council of State Ninth Chamber confirmed the decision for the same reasons, making the ruling final (Decision dated 24.10.2023, E:2021/1796 K:2023/3864).


My Evaluation

Before evaluating the company’s practice and the court ruling in this case, I want to stress that the tax reduction system for incentivized investments is extremely complicated and unmanageable. In many cases, incentives do not provide benefits at the time the investor needs them. Sometimes, tax savings stretch over many years, resulting in the incentive being less effective than expected. The main reason for these issues is that the reduced rate mainly applies to income derived from the incentivized investment.

Regarding the determination of income from incentivized investments, the main goal is to find the most accurate income amount possible. It appears that the legal regulation and the tax administration assume that income from completely new investments can be identified from accounting records, but this is not always possible. Some part of revenue and direct costs related to new investments can be separated, but accurately determining income requires allocation of various revenues and expenses using appropriate distribution keys. This method is reasonable and often more accurate than the formula foreseen for expansion investments.

Therefore, in the specific case discussed, it is easy to assume that the company’s calculation is closer to reality than the tax audit report’s calculation.

I also agree with the court’s reasoning that applying the expansion investment formula to completely new investments by analogy is neither legally feasible nor results in an accurate income determination. However, the use of distribution keys to allocate income more accurately than by analogy can be acceptable if it yields more realistic results. This should be seen not as applying a provision by analogy but as seeking the income figure closest to reality.

Finally, it should be noted that tracking income from completely new investments separately in legal accounts is often impossible. In the case at hand, even the tax auditor could not perform this calculation and tried to apply the formula foreseen for expansion investments based on assumptions. If the activity includes more than one completely new investment, it may be impossible to calculate income without any distribution keys from legal records. It is not correct to tie taxation and incentives to such impractical applications.


Source: Recep Bıyık / Ekonomim.com

  • Growth through innovation/creativity:
    Rather than be constrained by ideas for new products, services and new markets coming from just a few people, a Thinking Corporation can tap into the employees.
  • Increased profits:
    The corporation will experience an increase in profits due to savings in operating costs as well as sales from new products, services and ventures.
  • Higher business values:
    The link between profits and business value means that the moment a corporation creates a new sustainable level of profit, the business value is adjusted accordingly.
  • Lower staff turnover:
    This, combined with the culture that must exist for innovation and creativity to flourish, means that new employees will be attracted to the organization.

Leave a Reply

How can we help you?

Contact us at the Consulting WP office nearest to you or submit a business inquiry online.

See our gallery
Looking for an Expert Business Consultant?