Input VAT on Destroyed Goods and Liable Parties
- 15 April 2025
- Posted by: emsaldenetim
- Category: Announcements
Input VAT on Destroyed Goods and Liable Parties
VAT on Destroyed Goods and Liabilities of the Parties
Last month, the Ministry of Finance published General Communiqué No. 113 on Value Added Tax (VAT) in the Official Gazette on December 5, 2009. This communiqué introduced regulations under the title “VAT on Goods That Have Passed Their Usage Period or Become Unusable,” which particularly concerns the pharmaceutical and food sectors.
In this regulation, the Ministry of Finance made the following statement, summarizing the issue based on the understanding that there was uncertainty regarding this matter in cases referred to the Revenue Administration:
“Where goods in stock that have passed their usage period or have become unusable for any other reason are destroyed under official commissions or an Appraisal Commission as prescribed by the relevant legislation, VAT paid on the acquisition of such goods cannot be deducted as the goods are considered as ‘wasted’ under the VAT Law (Article 30/c).
In this context, the VAT paid on wasted goods and previously deducted should be excluded from the deduction accounts by including it in the ‘Additional VAT’ line of the VAT declaration for the period that includes the date of destruction.”
This regulation by the Ministry of Finance has caused significant difficulties, particularly in the aforementioned sectors.
In practice, as mentioned by the Ministry, there was no such uncertainty. Various provincial tax offices and tax directorates had already clarified this issue through several official opinions. Since 2002, the Ministry had provided consistent opinions stating, “VAT paid on the acquisition of goods that have passed their usage period or have become unusable and are destroyed may be deducted.”
In practice, this change in the Ministry’s opinion seems to have emerged due to internal uncertainties, without any legislative changes to justify it. In fact, the previous opinion was supported by judicial decisions. For example, the Council of State, in its decision E. 2002/3313 K.2004/4389, ruled that “the VAT paid on goods that have passed their usage period and are destroyed, with the approval of the Appraisal Commission, cannot be considered as VAT on wasted goods under Article 30/c of the VAT Law, and therefore may be deducted.”
While I am not addressing whether this shift in opinion is correct in this article (I will leave that for another article), I want to focus on the change in opinion itself.
This shift shows that there is no guarantee as to how the same legal provisions will be interpreted in three to five years. Such changes in opinions clearly undermine legal certainty and the principle of legal stability, making it more difficult for taxpayers to foresee their obligations.
Moreover, the Ministry has retroactively applied this change in opinion, instructing many companies to correct their VAT declarations for the periods prior to the date of destruction. This has exposed companies to the risk of audits.
Many companies, if they choose not to go to court, will make these corrections and end up paying hefty late payment interest. Although those who received official opinions or filed voluntary declarations without penalties may avoid criminal risks, those who file declarations with a reservation of rights (ihtirazi kayıt) will face the risk of penalties, as court precedents generally hold that a reservation of rights and voluntary declaration cannot be combined.
The high rate of late payment interest, compared to inflation and market interest rates, is well-known. Furthermore, this interest expense cannot be written off as an expense.
No one has the right to cause such significant financial losses for businesses, as such actions undermine entrepreneurship and deter foreign investment.
If the Ministry adopts this opinion and does not reconsider it, it should at least announce that this new opinion will apply moving forward, rather than revisiting the past.
If past decisions are to be reconsidered and companies are asked to correct their VAT declarations, action should be taken against those who misdirected the application with these opinions or who misled practitioners through books or articles presenting the Ministry’s view, and the results should be made public.
If the old view was wrong and the new view is correct, those responsible for companies facing high late payment interest and/or penalties, and for the losses incurred by the Treasury under the new view, should be held accountable.
Otherwise, the bureaucracy will continue to interpret the same legal provisions as it wishes, change its opinion as it pleases, and make everyone liable in the name of law.
Bumin Doğrusöz
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
Contact us at the Consulting WP office nearest to you or submit a business inquiry online.